EB1A Visa: 10 Common Mistakes in Application Process & How to Avoid Them
- Brandosaur
- June 19, 2025
- 9:32 am
The EB1A visa, called the extraordinary ability green card, is a U.S. immigration category for individuals at the top of their field. It’s an employment-based first-preference visa for those who can demonstrate “extraordinary ability” through sustained national or international acclaim. To qualify, you must meet at least 3 out of 10 specific eligibility criteria (or show a one-time major achievement like an Oscar or Olympic medal) and prove you will continue working in your field in the United States.
In other words, being good at your job isn’t enough; you need to show you’re among the small percentage at the very top of your field. Even highly accomplished applicants can be stuck during the EB1A process. Many qualified people undermine their chances with common mistakes, which lead to delays, RFEs, or denials.
Below are 10 common EB1A green card mistakes that often result in rejections, and you can strengthen your visa application if you understand these pitfalls and how to avoid them.
1. Misunderstanding the EB1A Criteria
It is a common error to misinterpret “extraordinary ability” because some applicants think that if they are highly skilled or have a Ph.D. degree, it is enough to qualify. But USCIS’s bar for EB1A is extremely high because they require proof of sustained national or international acclaim with evidence that you’re one of the best in your field, not just a talented professional.
How to Avoid: You can avoid this error by reviewing the EB1A eligibility criteria and your profile honestly. Make sure that you have strong evidence for at least three of the ten criteria. A single accomplishment isn’t enough to demonstrate a pattern of excellence over time. If you don’t know about meeting the EB1A standard, you should get a free evaluation from an expert who can identify any gaps through objective review and guide you on strengthening your profile before you apply.
Book a Free Consultation
Unsure how to kick off your social media strategy? Schedule a call with one of our experts, and we'll guide you every step of the way.
2. Mistakes in Forms & Paperwork
If you make minor paperwork errors (using outdated USCIS forms, leaving required sections blank, or missing a signature), it can lead to major issues. USCIS will reject or deny petitions for simple clerical mistakes, even a missing signature or an unchecked box can trigger a denial.
How to Avoid: You should always use the latest form versions from USCIS, and don’t forget to double-check them for completeness and accuracy. Fill out every field (write “N/A” if something doesn’t apply) and sign everywhere required. It’s wise to have someone else review your application as well; a fresh pair of eyes can catch errors you missed. Investing extra time to perfect the paperwork can save you from a needless denial.
3. Submitting Insufficient & Irrelevant Evidence
If you submit insufficient evidence of your achievements, it can cause rejection of the EB1A visa application, which is common today. Sending a pile of documents that don’t clearly prove your excellence won’t help. According to the USCIS’s new updates, it wants concrete, objective proof of your achievement with your personal statements. If your evidence doesn’t directly address the EB1A criteria, your case can fall apart.
How to Avoid: Align your evidence with the EB1A criteria because quality matters more than quantity. That’s why each piece of documentation should align with the specific eligibility criterion for EB1A. They can be proof of major awards, press articles about you, patents, or high-impact publications, which are evidence of your impact. If you find gaps in your evidence, work on building up your profile to bolster those areas before applying.
4. Poor Organization & No Clear Narrative
A disorganized petition can make it hard for the officer to understand your qualifications. If you just dump documents without context, important details may be overlooked because not including a clear cover letter or summary that ties your evidence to the criteria is another common oversight.
How to Avoid: Organize your petition logically and start with a concise cover letter that highlights your top achievements and links them to the EB1A criteria you meet. Make sure that you structure your exhibits by category (Awards, Publications, Media Coverage) and label each item clearly. By doing so, the officer can easily follow your story and see how each piece of evidence demonstrates your extraordinary ability because a well-structured petition makes their job easier.
5. Weak or Generic Recommendation Letters
The Mistake: Recommendation letters are meant to validate your extraordinary ability, but weak or generic letters can undermine your case. If your recommendation letters only give broad praise without specifics (“she is a great researcher and hard worker”), they cannot impress the USCIS officer.
How to Avoid: You should secure strong, specific letters (with concrete achievements or impacts you’ve made) from respected experts in your industry. For guidance, you can share an EB1A recommendation letter guide with your referees so they know how to align recommendation letters to USCIS standards.
Related Article: How Do You Write a Letter of Recommendation for Immigration?
6. Overlooking the Importance of Media Coverage
Evidence of media coverage (published material about you) is one EB1A criterion that applicants often ignore. If you have zero press mentions or articles about your work, USCIS may doubt that your acclaim is widespread.
How to Avoid: You should highlight any public recognition you’ve received and seek opportunities to increase it if needed. Include copies of articles, interviews, or press releases featuring your achievements. If you lack media coverage, you should work with public relations professionals like Brandosaur to raise your profile. When assembling your petition, attach those press pieces (with translations if not in English) to demonstrate that your work has attracted attention beyond your immediate circle. Media coverage is strong proof that you have national or international recognition in your field.
7. Not Demonstrating Sustained Acclaim (& Future Plans)
EB1A requires sustained acclaim, but it may fall short if your petition highlights an old accomplishment but shows little recent activity. Likewise, if you fail to mention that you plan to continue working in your field after getting the green card (a USCIS requirement), it can hurt your case.
How to Avoid: To overcome this challenge, you should show that your excellence is ongoing and future-focused. For this purpose, you should include your recent achievements to prove you’re still at the top of your field, not just resting on past laurels. You should clearly state your future plans in the U.S., e.g., upcoming projects, research, or ventures you will pursue. This demonstrates to the officer that your extraordinary contributions will continue, satisfying the “sustained acclaim” aspect of EB1A.
8. Missing Deadlines & Rushing the Application
If you fail to meet deadlines, the application process can be fatal to your case. Missing an important USCIS due date (for example, an RFE response deadline) will likely result in a denial or case closure. Even without a fixed deadline, rushing your filing at the last minute often causes mistakes or omissions due to time pressure.
How to Avoid: Must stay organized, not procrastinate, keep track of all deadlines, and give yourself plenty of buffer time. You should focus on submitting filings and responses well before they’re due. That way, you can double-check everything and handle any unexpected issues.
9. Ineffective Responses to Requests for Evidence (RFEs)
EB1A visa success depends on how you handle an RFE because it can make or break your EB1A petition. A common mistake is responding poorly to your application by dumping irrelevant documents and providing an incomplete reply. Flooding USCIS with unrelated papers can backfire, and not addressing all the RFE questions will almost guarantee a denial.
How to Avoid: Be focused and thorough if you get an RFE. Read the RFE carefully to understand exactly what the officer needs. Then submit a targeted response that addresses each issue directly. Provide the specific additional evidence or clarification requested because a well-organized, prompt RFE response can rescue your case.
10. Trying to DIY Without Professional Guidance
The EB1A process is complex and its policies are updated regularly, so going it alone can be risky. Without expert guidance, you might misinterpret the criteria or overlook policy changes. Many EB1A denials happen not due to the applicant lacking merit, but because of avoidable mistakes in how the case was prepared and mistakes a professional could have caught.
How to Avoid: Consider getting expert help because an experienced immigration attorney or EB1A consultant can evaluate your profile, help select your strongest evidence, and ensure your petition meets all requirements. Services like Brandosaur offer free eligibility evaluations and can assist with profile building, public relations, and petition preparation. You can file on your own, but if you have expert support, it can make the difference between denial and approval.
FAQs
What are the common mistakes in EB1A visa applications that can lead to a denial?
Many EB1A green card self-petitioners fall prey to common mistakes in U.S. visa applications that jeopardize their case. Frequent errors include submitting incomplete or outdated forms, misunderstanding the strict EB1A eligibility criteria, poor organization, generic recommendation letters, and mistakes in forms & paperwork.
What are the EB1A extraordinary ability criteria, and how can I meet them to avoid a denial?
To qualify for an EB1A extraordinary ability green card, you must satisfy at least 3 out of 10 specific criteria or show a one-time major achievement (like a Nobel Prize) that proves you’ve risen to the top of your field. These criteria include evidence such as major awards, published scholarly articles, memberships in elite associations, high salary, significant original contributions, and other markers of outstanding achievement.
Does meeting the three EB1A criteria guarantee approval of my EB1A green card?
No, meeting three criteria is necessary but not sufficient for EB1A approval. Many applicants mistakenly believe that checking off any 3 of the 10 criteria automatically secures an EB1A green card, but USCIS also conducts a final merits determination to assess the overall strength of your accomplishments.
